(Jason Stein)
This has been an unusually cold winter. We have learned what a polar vortex is, and had more school snow days than my 30-something memory can recall. The winters of recent past had cold and snowy days, but there was always a break when temperatures would rise and the snow would melt. These thaws helped make the winter months feel shorter and cleared much of the snow from our sidewalks. This winter’s constant cold has highlighted an ongoing challenge: to keep our city walkable, even in the winter months.
When the sidewalks are covered with six inches or more of snow, pedestrians tend to walk in the street. Among them are elementary school children walking to and from their schools and bus stops; disabled or senior individuals who have challenges walking under the best of weather conditions; and those who use public transportation. Walking in the streets is dangerous and a public safety issue.
Recently, I posted a question on my Facebook page: Should Cleveland Heights enforce the sidewalk snow removal ordinance by issuing a warning for the first offense and a ticket for subsequent offences (and why)? In 2011, at a city council meeting, I requested ideas from the public to encourage residents and businesses to make their sidewalks passable by shoveling them after a snowfall. At that time, I received no more than a handful of responses. To my surprise, my Facebook question quickly had 240 comments!
Most who responded indicated that they felt this issue needed the attention of city council, and needed a resolution. There was no clear consensus on how the city should approach the issue.
City council and staff discussed the issue at our Feb. 9 city council meeting. In a lengthy discussion, we dissected numerous options, including the three most popular from respondents to my Facebook post:
- The city should clear the sidewalks, like University Heights and Shaker Heights: This would solve the problem. However, the cost would exceed $500,000 a year. Cleveland Heights’s income tax rate is 2 percent, Shaker Heights’s is 2.25 percent and University Heights’s is 2.5 percent. The city would need additional tax revenue to add this service.
- Fine residents and businesses that do not clear their sidewalks: This option would increase compliance and lead to the majority of sidewalks being shoveled after a snowfall. Exceptions would be made, however, for the disabled, seniors and others who are unable to clear their sidewalks. The city could collaborate with schools and nonprofits to assist those who cannot clear their own sidewalks, but this would not be a perfect system and would leave a percentage of sidewalks filled with snow. Of course, there would likely be complaints from residents who receive warnings and/or fines, as the city already experiences with tall grass citations in the summer.
- Private snow-removal businesses should offer sidewalk snow removal with their driveway service: The city can encourage licensed snow-removal businesses to offer sidewalk snow removal. Certainly, paying for snow removal for the season would be less expensive than receiving a few tickets. Many residents, however, including myself, do not have any intention of paying for snow removal (I clear my own driveway and sidewalk).
In the end, it was decided that:
- The city’s public works department will map out the city’s main roads and design a plan to plow those sidewalks.
- The city will encourage private snow-plow businesses to offer sidewalk snow removal.
- The city will look for best practices from other municipalities that have programs to assist the elderly and disabled in clearing their sidewalks.
- When the city receives a complaint of unpassable sidewalks at a residence or business, the city will send out an inspector and issue a warning.
- When the city receives a complaint that a private snow-plow service has covered a sidewalk with snow, the city will issue a citation, when warranted, to the service provider.
- The city will create and distribute a guide to educate and assist residents with tips for keeping sidewalks and driveway aprons clear during the winter months.
- Council and city staff will continue to discuss this issue through the summer in preparation for walkable sidewalks during the 2014–15 winter season.
It does take a village, and Cleveland Heights has great neighbors throughout our “village.” I have heard stories of residents who go above and beyond, plowing neighbors’ sidewalks, cutting grass for a neighbor, helping a neighbor put trash out on the tree lawn, starting a street club and contributing in other ways.
I want to recognize those Cleveland Heights heroes who make our city so special, and encourage others to be more neighborly. With this in mind, I am establishing “Councilman Stein’s Outstanding Neighbor of the Month” award, to be awarded to CH residents who go above and beyond to help their neighbors and improve their neighborhood. To nominate a neighbor for this recognition, fill out the online form at councilmanstein.blogspot.com/ or contact me at jstein@clvhts.com or 440-253-9613 for a nomination form.
MisterG says
I hope this doesn’t mean a new tax for an already over taxed city (our income taxes may be slightly lower, but our property taxes are very high).
Most major cities issue citations and ticket homeowners for not shoveling their sidewalks. Their laws, so allow a reasonable amount of time after a snow fall has finished for this to be done.
As for those residents that have difficulty shoveling their sidewalks, they somehow manage to have their driveways plowed and their grass cut.
If the city will ticket for tall grass, which is nothing more than an eye-sore, they certainly should enforce the sidewalk shoveling laws that represents a safety issue.
Chaya says
How about a gentle reminder to residents that garbage is to be placed outside at 7 PM–not 3 PM?
Hieghtser says
I propose a trade, no more citations for lawn care in exchange for dealing with this safety hazard.
Or better yet, maybe there are other superfluous things the city is paying for and can divert the monies to this public safety issue and indeed do like UH and clear the walks instead of, say, holding hearings on whether corporations are people or sending Putin notices that we are a nuclear free zone or grants to artists etc…
Reality check, if snow falls while you are out of town, you can get socked by fines.
CH Resident for 40 years says
It is ridiculous to enforce that residents shoudl plow their sidewalks when the sidewalks actually belong to the CITY!.. The City makes us fix them, maintain them, etc and now we also have to plow them, even though officially the sidewalks are city property! Other Cities have little tiny snowplows with a “V” blade that plows the sidewalks.. that’s city services! CH barely salts the sidestreets, if at all, due to budget cuts, and now they want to enforce this?!! I agree that it is a hazard for children to walk in the street, that’s why the City shoudl be plowing their property! Get rid of some of the dead weight in Administration in City Hall to pay for it and increase our police and fire and emt units. That’s where we need services, not the dead weight of Administrators h’rumphing pretending to advancing ithe city when we have thousands of vacant homes and commercial real estate. Where is the City to revitalize Severance Mall? Stores are noving outta there in droves and no visible efforts are being made to attract new businesses… Learn from the City of Beachwood who harbor incubator companies that grow and develop and settle in their city. It’s a win-win. CH is so worried about miniscule details in zoning laws, nothing ever gets done! Jason, forget about this header for this, and try to attract new business and tax revenue to the City, so the City can pay for this. Wow! What a misdirection of efforts.
Frustrated says
This is very frustrating. I don’t understand how the city can even consider issuing citations for not taking care of city property. What’s next – will we be issued citations for not salting your side streets? And please don’t compare this to mowing the tree lawn. That can be done by the same person mowing the lawn and is not dependent upon the timing of a snowfall. I am often out of town during the week. Are you then expecting my wife to shovel the sidewalks?
MisterG says
It is normal practice for most cities to require the homeowner to be responsible for maintaining and taking care of the sidewalk in front of one’s home.
I’d rather shovel the sidewalk myself or pay someone to do it, than to be hit with another tax for the city to do it at a higher cost and less efficiently.
CHer says
When we can fine the city for the pot holes and unsalted streets, then you can consider fining residents for sidewalk clearing.
But every time the snow falls and I think the driving is bad, turns out it’s only bad until you reach the border CH and then the roads are altogether more clear if not completely so.
Go from CH to UH and you will see an amazing difference even on the side streets. And you will also see their little sidewalk clearing mobile doing its thing. We absolutely need one of those on our streets, but just as absolutely are paying too much in taxes. Cut the extras and focus on what’s important in the budget.